Are these symptoms related to gearbox problems?

[M@r]{]

I assumed the following was a sign of impending gearbox failure, but having spoken to someone i\'m now having doubts.

The issue is this. When backing off in 2nd I can hear a grinding / rattle noise that appears to be coming from the gearbox area. On my last event this has now started happening in 3rd and to a certain extent 4th. I can select gear no problem and there is no noise on tick over, when cruising or when accelarating.

So does this sound like the gearbox? I have been told as this only happens when backing off it is unlikely. It wasnt that long ago I had the clutch replaced, the 2nd gear problem was evident at the time and is still evident since. The clutch did come with some sort of bearing. i have the standard FD push or pull type what ever it is.

Any thoughts? Money is tight and I dont want to swap it over if it isnt needed.


Thanks

[Gavin_RX8]

If its when backing off, my first thoughts would be to check the mounts as there could be excessiev movement.

[clive]

Check the prop u/j\'s because these will give the symptoms you describe

[M@r]{]

Cheers guys :Thumbs-up

Any more opinions? Could really do with ruling out the gearbox before I pay to get it swapped out!!